Hallmark Christmas Movies Are My Self-Care—Here's How Science Backs It Up
The holiday season can be a stressful time for many. From the pressure to find the perfect gifts to navigating family gatherings, the most wonderful time of the year can also feel overwhelming. For some, turning to the soothing, feel-good worlds of Hallmark Christmas movies provides a much-needed respite.
"I've been watching Hallmark Christmas movies religiously for years," says Sarah, a 32-year-old office manager. "There's just something so comforting and uplifting about them. They help me unwind and de-stress, especially during the busy holiday season."
Sarah isn't alone in her love of these saccharine seasonal stories. Hallmark's annual "Countdown to Christmas" programming block has become a beloved tradition, with the network premiering over 40 new Christmas movies each year. And the demand only seems to be growing - Hallmark saw a 17% increase in viewership for its 2021 holiday slate compared to 2020.
So what is it about these movies that makes them such effective self-care tools? According to psychologists, there are a few key reasons.
Familiarity and Predictability Provide Comfort
One of the hallmarks (pun intended) of Hallmark Christmas movies is their familiar, predictable storylines. Whether it's a busy city executive rediscovering the magic of the holidays, a small-town romance blossoming, or a Christmas tradition being revived, the plot points tend to follow a reliable formula.
"Predictability can be very soothing, especially during stressful times," explains Dr. Carla Manly, a clinical psychologist and author of "Joy from Fear." "When we know what to expect, it creates a sense of safety and security. Hallmark movies tap into that by delivering the same comforting narrative over and over."
This familiarity can have a powerful effect on our mental state. "Watching a Hallmark movie is like slipping into a warm, familiar blanket," says Manly. "It activates the parts of our brain associated with positive emotions and reduces activity in the areas linked to anxiety and stress."
Positive Emotions and Mood Boosts
Beyond the comfort of predictability, Hallmark movies also induce positive emotions through their uplifting storylines and feel-good resolutions.
"These movies are intentionally designed to make viewers feel good," explains Dr. Krystine Batcho, a professor of psychology at Le Moyne College who studies nostalgia. "They're filled with themes of kindness, generosity, and the magic of the holiday season. This triggers the release of neurotransmitters like dopamine and serotonin, which are associated with happiness and well-being."
Batcho's research has found that watching nostalgic media like Hallmark movies can actually improve mood and overall life satisfaction. "There's a sense of joy, hope, and wonder that these movies evoke," she says. "And that can have a powerful, uplifting effect, especially for people who are dealing with stress or difficult emotions."
Escapism and Stress Relief
For many viewers, Hallmark movies also provide a much-needed escape from the demands and pressures of everyday life.
"When I'm feeling overwhelmed, there's nothing better than getting lost in the cozy, picturesque worlds of these movies," says Sarah. "For a couple hours, I can just shut off my brain and immerse myself in a feel-good story. It's a mental vacation, really."
Dr. Manly agrees that this escapist quality is a key part of the Hallmark appeal. "In a world that often feels chaotic and stressful, these movies offer a peaceful, harmonious alternative," she explains. "There's no real conflict or negativity - just heartwarming stories that allow viewers to temporarily disengage from their worries and anxieties."
This ability to transport people to a more joyful, serene emotional state is what makes Hallmark movies so effective as a self-care tool. "They provide a healthy, constructive way to manage stress and regulate our moods," says Manly. "Watching them is like pressing the reset button on our mental and emotional well-being."
The Nostalgia Factor
For many viewers, the appeal of Hallmark movies goes beyond their feel-good narratives and escapist qualities. There's also a strong element of nostalgia at play.
"A lot of people have fond memories of watching these kinds of movies with their families during the holidays," explains Dr. Batcho. "The familiar settings, characters, and storylines can trigger feelings of warmth, comfort, and security from our childhoods."
This nostalgic connection is particularly powerful for those who may be dealing with difficult emotions or life transitions during the holiday season. "When we're feeling lonely, stressed, or disconnected, revisiting that sense of holiday magic and togetherness can be incredibly soothing," says Batcho.
In fact, research has shown that nostalgia can have a range of psychological benefits, including increased feelings of social connectedness, improved mood, and better coping mechanisms for dealing with adversity.
"Hallmark movies tap into that universal human desire to recapture the joy and wonder of the holidays," explains Batcho. "And for many people, indulging in that nostalgia is an important part of their self-care routine."
A Guilt-Free Guilty Pleasure
Of course, not everyone views Hallmark Christmas movies in a purely positive light. Some critics dismiss them as overly saccharine, predictable, or divorced from reality. And there's no denying that they offer an idealized, feel-good version of the holiday season.
However, for many viewers, that's precisely the point. "Sometimes, we just need a break from the harsh realities of the world," says Sarah. "Hallmark movies allow me to indulge in a fantasy version of Christmas that's free of conflict or stress. And there's no shame in that."
In fact, psychologists like Dr. Manly argue that allowing ourselves to embrace "guilty pleasures" like Hallmark movies can be an important part of self-care. "We live in a society that often values productivity and efficiency over rest and relaxation," she explains. "But taking time to simply enjoy something that makes us feel good, without any judgement, is crucial for our mental health."
Manly believes that the stigma around "lowbrow" entertainment like Hallmark movies can actually be counterproductive. "If something brings you comfort and joy, and doesn't harm anyone else, then it has value," she says. "We shouldn't feel guilty about indulging in those kinds of activities. They're an important way to recharge and reset."
So, the next time you find yourself reaching for the remote to tune into a Hallmark Christmas movie, remember that you're engaging in a scientifically-backed self-care ritual. It may not be highbrow, but it just might be the antidote you need to the stresses of the holiday season.